Some Modesto city leaders continued to defend the use of $824,613 in taxpayer funds, while voting to settle a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the city’s controversial mask ban at protests.
At a special meeting Monday evening, the Modesto City Council unanimously approved eliminating the face covering provision in its ordinance on protests, which was originally passed in 2019 but not deployed until the summer of 2025 during anti-Trump and ICE demonstrations. The council also amended the ordinance to allow the use of “ordinary bicycle helmets” for protesters and protective gear for journalists.
The council voted 6-1 to approve the third increase of an additional $108,658 in attorney fees. That brings the total amount paid to its own special counsel, Deborah Fox of Meyers Nave, to nearly $460,000 for defending the ordinance, in addition to having to pay the opposing attorney fees of $366,455 to the American Civil Liberties Union, who represented the plaintiffs, as part of the settlement.
In June, a federal judge issued a preliminary injunction in the case which stopped the city from enforcing the mask ordinance.
Councilman Chris Ricci, who cast the lone dissenting vote, declined The Modesto Focus’s request for comment, citing that the settlement discussion was a closed-session item. Ricci also voted against the council’s last attorney fee increase of up to $349,500 in early April.
At Monday’s meeting, after hearing more than a dozen public comments from advocates and community members who expressed disappointment over the city council’s waste of tax dollars and disregard for community concerns, Mayor Sue Zwahlen responded that she did her best to analyze each situation despite “some of the comments that have been made towards me and the ridicule and the tone.”
One of her biggest concerns, Zwahlen said, is how to determine who is a real journalist, especially considering the technology available to citizens. She said she was concerned about people giving themselves “self-designation” as reporters.
“I was concerned about the welfare of journalists, also concerned about the welfare of our residents and anyone that chooses to be in the public,” Zwahlen said. “Also, our law enforcement needs to have the necessary tools and be able to do their job to the best of their ability, so that’s the reason that I made the decisions that I did.”
When interviewed by The Modesto Focus, some council members acknowledged the high cost of the lawsuit, but defended the spending decision and the outcome of having a revised mandate in place.
Councilman Jeremiah Williams, vice mayor of Modesto, said he respects freedom of speech and the right to protest, but he hopes there’s no need to protest and therefore no need for a mask ordinance.
“We’ll take out what is unconstitutional. However, there were other pieces of that needed to stay so there could be peaceful protesting,” Williams said. “The money was spent to help the cause, to help those who want to be able to protest without being harmed.”
Councilmember Nick Bavaro said his initial support for the original ordinance was to provide public safety measures to residents, visitors and businesses during the demonstrations. He said he had no pushback from his constituents.
“People in my district were in favor of what the council was doing… Most of the people who disagreed were those who showed up at the meetings expressing their displeasure,” said Bavaro, who represents District 4 to the east side of downtown Modesto. “The vast majority of people in my district support law enforcement. I get calls all the time from constituents who want more involvement with the police, such as dealing with traffic issues.”
Bavaro said the city deals with lawsuits all the time, and it’s common to hire legal counsel and pay for legal fees. In this case, he said, he respects the ruling, though he may not agree with it.
“(Whether) the money was well spent or not, that would be a debatable discussion, but for me, public safety is the number one issue, not how much we were going to spend,” Bavaro said. “As a councilmember, I need to always put the priority of safety regardless of the cost.”
Leqi Zhong is the First Amendment reporter for the nonprofit Central Valley Journalism Collaborative. Contact her at leqi@cvlocaljournalism.org.
