A pregnant protester who was pushed down and pepper sprayed by ICE agents in Modesto is speaking out and asking Valley leaders to take action, in a case that has drawn national attention.
Ceres resident Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, a U.S. citizen who is 12 weeks pregnant, recounted being taken to the ground and handcuffed by federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents Sunday afternoon in the parking lot of the Stanislaus County jail.
Video of the arrest circulated quickly on social media, and has been reported on by national outlets including ABC World News Tonight, NBC Nightly News, and People magazine.
Vargas Andrade, a mother of two, was acting as a legal observer monitoring immigration enforcement when the altercation happened.
“Being pregnant, my first thought was my (unborn) baby, my kids. What was going to happen?” said the 23-year-old Monday during a press conference.
Stanislaus County officials have scheduled a community town hall to discuss immigration enforcement at 6:30 p.m. Wednesday at the Salvation Army Community Center in south Modesto. Speakers will include prominent area immigration attorneys, Sheriff Jeff Dirkse and staff from U.S. Rep. Adam Gray’s office.
Patrick Kolasinski, who will be among the featured speakers and represents Vargas Andrade, said her family is exploring the possibility of a civil suit. He also questioned local leadership and whether area law enforcement was aiding federal immigration enforcement efforts.
It is not the first violent encounter between ICE and Stanislaus County residents to garner national attention.
In April, ICE officers shot Carlos Ivan Mendoza Hernandez, 36, during a traffic stop near Interstate 5 in Patterson. ICE agents said he tried to run over an officer and was wanted for questioning in a homicide in El Salvador. Mendoza Hernandez, who is also represented by Kolasinski, denied both claims, and Salvadoran records show he was acquitted in that case in 2019. He remains in ICE custody.
What happened Sunday?

Credit: Video courtesy Patrick Kolasinski
The encounter outside the Stanislaus County jail began about noon Sunday. Vargas Andrade said she was parked in the lot, watching ICE vehicles as part of a volunteer network that alerts residents to agents’ movements.
Her sister-in-law, Monica Alvarado, offered a ride to a man walking out of the jail. As Alvarado drove off, about five ICE agents pulled her over.
Vargas Andrade said the agents then forced themselves into Alvarado’s vehicle to pull the man out and take him into custody. No warrant or deportation order was shown through this interaction, she said.
Vargas Andrade and her husband, Adolfo Talavera Alvarado, approached Alvarado’s vehicle and began to interact with the immigration agents. During this altercation, one of the agents alleged that Vargas Andrade slapped him, and then agents turned their attention to her.
She denies assaulting the officer, and was live-streaming on TikTok at the time of the altercation. On video, agents can be seen taking her to the ground, where she landed on her stomach as bystanders shouted that she was pregnant. An agent deployed pepper-spray at her and her husband.
In a written statement Monday, Kolasinski said multiple videos of the incident contradict the agents’ claim that Vargas Andrade assaulted them.
He called for a thorough and transparent examination of Alvarado’s detention, the force used against Vargas Andrade and her treatment in custody, and urged the sheriff and local elected officials to disclose the nature and extent of any help deputies have given ICE.
“ICE is not supposed to be detaining U.S. citizens,” said Kolasinski. “They’re not gods. … If they’re law enforcement, they should enforce and follow the law. It’s that simple”
Vargas Andrade was taken 50 minutes away to the ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) office in Stockton.
Despite repeatedly telling officials she was pregnant, she said she was held without medical care for more than two hours. She wasn’t allowed to speak to her family or her legal counsel on the scene of the incident, Modesto attorney Harlan Diven.
Kolasinski and Diven have been closely following the recent surge of ICE detentions across San Joaquin and Stanislaus counties, fielding requests for representation.
Vargas Andrade’s younger sister, Valeria Vargas, told The Modesto Focus outside the detention center that her sister is considered a high-risk pregnancy with her Type 2 diabetes, and that their family was extremely concerned because she had experienced two previous miscarriages.
Valeria Vargas called an ambulance for her sister while she was in detention, which is how Vargas Andrade was eventually seen by paramedics and taken to San Joaquin County General Hospital.
Representatives with the Stockton ICE Detention Center could not be reached for comment.
Paramedics found she had high blood sugar and blood pressure initially, but she has since been cleared by doctors. Vargas Andrade spent about five hours in ICE custody before being released without charges.
Despite the ordeal, Vargas Andrade is determined to continue supporting and informing her community.
“We’re not going to stop helping the community, even though this happened,” she said. “We’re not going to stop helping the community because we want our immigrant neighbors to feel safe here, even if there’s all this going on.”

Concern about local law enforcement involvement
In January 2025, Sheriff Dirske released a video discussing SB 54, the California law that prevents state and local law enforcement resources from being used for federal immigration enforcement, including information, personnel and facilities.
The exception is in cases of those accused of serious or violent felonies.
It’s what Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Department spokesman Erich Layton pointed to when asked for comment about Vargas’s detainment in the parking lot outside their offices.
Still, community members have raised questions about Stanislaus County sheriff’s deputies collaborating with federal immigration agents. A recent video showing deputies and ICE officers chatting together cordially outside the department headquarters on Hackett Road has been widely shared.
On Monday afternoon, Layton said he has not seen the video in question and therefore cannot comment.
Stanislaus County Board of Supervisors chairman Vito Chiesa expressed his confidence in the sheriff’s department handling of ICE-related activity.
“The sheriff has made it abundantly clear that he’s not cooperating with ICE,” he said.
Stanislaus, Modesto officials react
Chiesa’s fellow Stanislaus County Supervisor Channce Condit said he’s “absolutely” concerned about increased ICE activity in the Valley.
“We all should be,” he said.
“I just think we need to have clarity,” said Condit, whose district stretches from south Modesto and Ceres to the west side of Stanislaus County. “We need to hear from the sheriff, the congressman’s staff and immigration attorneys so people know what to do and the resources available, if they need them.”
After the weekend incident he has promptly organized a community town hall about immigration issues for Wednesday. He is hosting the event at the south Modesto Salvation Army Community Center, 1649 Las Vegas St.
The Modesto Police Department released a statement on Monday afternoon, reiterating it upholds the state law, and does not use personnel or resources to conduct or assist ICE.
Councilmember Chris Ricci criticized the sheriff’s office for allowing ICE to use their parking lot. He said he doesn’t like seeing masked federal officers driving around the city without license plates, arresting people without warrants.
“I don’t believe that they should be violating people’s constitutional rights, and that’s what we’re seeing over and over again with these guys,” Ricci said. “I think they are damaging public safety. I think they damage trust in government, and I think they’re hurting our community.”
Modesto City Council Nick Bavaro said he couldn’t comment on the arrest of the pregnant protester but people have the right to protest as long as they aren’t interfering with law enforcement activities.
“It’s not a local issue. So I’m not in a position to make a comment about them one way or the other. It’s a federal issue,” Bavaro said. “If they’re violating any laws, that means the ICE agents, then they should be held accountable. I do support people’s right to protest.”
Bavaro, who represents District 4, an area in the east of downtown Modesto, said he received zero calls from his constituents complaining about the increased ICE activity in the city.
In June 2025, city council members from Modesto, Turlock, Riverbank, Oakdale and Patterson joined county supervisors and school district officials in a joint letter on ICE activity.
“We recognize the fear and distrust that residents are expressing amid the ongoing raids targeting innocent immigrant communities across our state,” the letter said. “Stanislaus County is home to hardworking families, diverse communities and a contributing immigrant population.”
Vargas Andrade doesn’t know what happened to the other man who was detained by ICE on Sunday.
“He thanked me for doing what we’re doing,” she said. “We’re still worried about him as a community, because he didn’t make it back to his family, so hopefully, if he was let out, hopefully he’s home now.”
The Modesto Focus accountability reporter Garth Stapley and Central Valley Journalism Collaborative First Amendment reporter Leqi Zhong contributed to this report.
Vivienne Aguilar is the arts/education reporter for The Modesto Focus, a project of the Central Valley Journalism Collaborative. Contact her at vivienne@themodestofocus.org.
Ximena Loeza is the bilingual communities reporter for The Modesto Focus, a project of the nonprofit Central Valley Journalism Collaborative. Contact her at ximena@themodestofocus.org.
